Child Welfare Turnover Crisis: How to Retain Social Workers

Woman in office, stressed with head in hands, sitting at desk with laptop, coffee cup, and paperwork, reflecting workforce development challenges.

The need for social workers is growing. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics predicts this demand will increase 12% in the next 10 years. About 74,000 openings for social workers are projected each year, on average, over the decade. Many of those openings are expected to result from the need to replace workers who transfer to different occupations or exit social work through retirement or disenchantment. (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics 2025)

At a time when staffing shortages plague the profession, accurate information about social work’s turnover rate is vital. Today, we will take a deeper dive into Child Welfare workforce turnover rates attempting to isolate causes and possible solutions. Currently, social work turnover in Child Welfare is estimated to be between 23% and 60% annually across private and public child welfare agencies. (Child Welfare League of America, 2022; Strolin-Goltzman, Kollar & Trinkle, 2016).

Causes of Child Welfare Turnover

 A study co-led by Assistant Professor Francie Julien-Chinn of the Thompson School of Social Work & Public Health at the University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa set out to discover why such high turnover rates exist in the field. The study was published in Elsevier in its May 2023 issue.

  • “We found that the burden of the work intensity was most associated with intentions to leave the workforce,” said Julien-Chinn.
  • Recognition of the negative consequences of caseworker burnout has prompted further research to identify factors that either contribute to or mitigate burnout. Findings from prior studies have indicated that (1) job stress (Lizano & Mor Barak, 2012), (2) time pressure (He, Phillips, Lizano, Rienks, & Leake, 2018), and (3) high caseloads (Thomas, Kohli, & Choi, 2014) represent job demands that can lead to higher levels of caseworker burnout.
  • In all these studies, factors associated with caseworker burnout were most often viewed as unchanging throughout a caseworker’s career.

Strategies to Reduce Turnover and Boost Child Welfare Retention

To reduce turnover in child welfare, the studies all concluded that agencies must:

  1. Provide high-quality supervision and support.
  2. Offer opportunities for career advancement.
  3. Improve organizational culture to foster health and equity.
  4. Reduce job demands by managing caseloads.
  5. Enhance training and onboarding to better prepare and support workers.

One Child Welfare Caseworker Speaks

Despite the findings of the Child Welfare turnover studies conducted over the past ten years, the turnover rate has continued unabated. Every time a caseworker leaves an agency, the loss costs the agency 30% to 200% of the former employee’s annual salary. If agencies know what is causing this catastrophe, why have they not tried to mitigate the causes?

We asked one Child Welfare caseworker we correspond with why she thinks the agencies have been ineffective in their attempts to mitigate the causes of turnover.

GVT: “Why do you think the first Child Welfare Agency you worked for wouldn’t improve working conditions to retain your services?”

CWSW: “Because they couldn’t. The demands on Child Welfare agencies have been growing by leaps and bounds over the past ten years. The agency had obvious limits on how many case workers they could employ but had no control over the growing needs of the children and families they had sworn to serve.

GVT: Are you suggesting that there is no solution to the high rate of turnover in Child Welfare agencies?

CWSW: “No easy solution, certainly. The Child Welfare agency I worked for did invest in an upgraded human services software platform that my friends who are still there tell me cut down the paperwork burden by almost half. The reporting requirements become more complex every year, and those demands are swamping caseworkers. A modern software platform is a must. I wouldn’t consider working for an agency that hadn’t invested in one.”

GVT: “That, of course, is music to our ears, but what about the other issues; emotional burnout, supervisory support, career advancement, better training?

CWSW: “I was naive when I took a job at my first Child Welfare agency. Of course, I was swamped by my caseload, but my need to do everything perfectly was what put me under. The agency did everything they could to help me, but I had yet to learn that social services are not the magical solution to everyone’s problems. We can only do the best we can with what we have to work with. Some of the burden falls on the clients themselves. And nothing is ever perfect. Once we offer services across the board to the public, their needs will always outrun our resources.

“My advice to young people coming into the field is as long as you can truly tell yourself you’ve done the best you can in this real world of suffering and need, you are doing a great job. Take heart and stick with it. Your clients really need you.”

Related Reading on the FAMCare Blog: 

The Case Worker Turnover Crisis: How Technology Can Help Child Welfare Agencies Retain Their Best Talent
Explore how data-driven tools and modern case management systems can help agencies reduce burnout and retain their most experienced workers.

How Case Management Software Improves Child Welfare Outcomes
Learn how digital workflows and centralized data help caseworkers spend more time supporting children and families and less time managing paperwork.

This article was written by Frances Bennett, Guest Writer for FAMCare.

Share the Post:

Related: Learn more about our social work case management software