Gradual Erosion of Serious Mental Health Services

Silhouette of a head with crumpled paper representing thoughts and mental distress, illustrating the challenges of serious mental health issues and the erosion of care services.

How to deal with incurable serious mental illness has confounded well-intentioned social service professionals, medical practitioners, and government authorities for more than 75 years and has inadvertently led to the persistent erosion of care for the seriously mentally ill.

1961 – Erosion Begins

Deinstitutionalization as a policy for state hospitals began in the 1960s when we began to move people with severe mental illness from hospitals into the community. Society began to believe that mental hospitals were cruel and inhumane, that new antipsychotic medications could offer a cure, and that maintaining large state mental hospitals to simply house the seriously mentally ill was becoming too costly.

However well-intentioned, deinstitutionalization did not work out as well as expected.

  • People with severe mental illness can still be found in deplorable environments.
  • Medications have not successfully improved function in all patients even when they improve symptoms.
  • The institutional closings have deluged underfunded community services with new populations they are ill-equipped to handle.

1981 – Erosion Continues

While the Deinstitutionalization Movement began in the 1960s with the intent of moving care to community settings, the 1981 funding cuts are widely cited as a major turning point that weakened the infrastructure for outpatient care.

President Reagan’s signing of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1981 effectively reduced federal funding for mental health services by converting categorical grants into block grants to states. This policy, coupled with the repeal of the 1980 Mental Health Systems Act, accelerated the process of deinstitutionalization, significantly reducing federal support for community mental health centers.

Key details of the 1981 action:

  • Reduced Federal Role: The Act, signed on August 13, 1981, aimed to lower federal spending, giving states more control but less overall funding.
  • Impact on Services: It repealed the Mental Health Systems Act of 1980, which had sought to improve services for the mentally ill, and resulted in a roughly 30% cut in federal mental health spending.
  • Deinstitutionalization Acceleration: The shift contributed to the closure of many state hospitals, leaving many individuals with chronic mental illnesses without adequate care, often resulting in homelessness or incarceration.

1975 -1991 – Supreme Court SMI Decisions

Beginning around 1975, court cases intended to protect the rights of the serious mentally ill began to find their way to the Supreme Court.

  • O’Connor v. Donaldson (1975): The Court ruled that a state cannot constitutionally confine a non-dangerous individual who can survive safely in freedom by themselves or with the help of willing family or friends. Mental illness alone is not enough to commit someone against their will.
  • Addington v. Texas (1979): The Court established that the burden of proof for involuntary civil commitment must be “clear and convincing evidence,” rather than the lower “preponderance of the evidence” standard used in typical civil cases.
  • Parham v. J.R. (1979): The Court addressed the commitment of minors, ruling that parents may commit their children to mental health facilities, but due process requires an independent review of the clinical decision.
  • Olmstead v. L.C. (1999): Considered the most important decision for people with disabilities, the Court held that unjustified institutionalization of persons with mental disabilities constitutes discrimination under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). States are required to provide community-based treatment for persons with mental disabilities when professionals determine it is appropriate, the affected person does not oppose it, and resources allow.

These court decisions have certainly limited the ability of state facilities to confine people in hospitals against their will and created conflict between laws that are intended to preserve liberty and prevent wrongful hospitalization on the one hand, and the need to identify and treat people early in their diseases on the other.

2025 – Federal Health Cuts Deepen Mental Health Crisis

 Perhaps one of the most impactful policy changes of 2025 was the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (H.R.1) enacted on July 4, involving unprecedented cuts to federal health and social safety net programs. An estimated $1 trillion in funding cuts to Medicaid and the rollback of expanded Affordable Care Act subsidies are expected to result in tens of millions of Americans losing health care coverage over the course of the next decade. Medicaid is the largest payer of mental health services in the United States.

Conclusion

Although preserving the rights of people with severe mental illness to be treated in the least restrictive settings is noble, it has allowed many people with SMI to “fall through the cracks” in the system or be re-hospitalized in what has been termed the “revolving door” of acute hospital admissions.

An even more egregious situation occurs when difficulty being admitted to a hospital leads to the homelessness of people with severe mental illness, who wander the streets in major cities, being arrested or dying.

Editorial Perspective

Policy shifts and funding reductions do not occur in isolation. They reshape the operational realities of agencies on the front lines — increasing documentation requirements, compliance oversight, and the pressure to demonstrate measurable outcomes.

In times of system strain, the ability to collect, analyze, and report accurate data becomes critical to sustainability. Agencies must be prepared not only to deliver services, but to clearly demonstrate their impact within evolving regulatory and funding environments.

For further reading:Woman reading on stack of books with FAMCare logo, symbolizing knowledge and ethical guidance in child protective services.

Share the Post: