Is Teletherapy as Effective as In-Person Counseling?

Smiling woman engaging in teletherapy session on laptop, surrounded by plants and cozy living room decor, illustrating modern mental health support.

In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, tele-behavioral health (TBH) became a practice norm almost overnight.

In an episode of National Public Radio’s The Pulse, Jonathan B. Singer, PhD, LCSW, an associate professor of social work at Loyola University Chicago, noted, “Health systems that previously said they would need five years to ramp up for telehealth service delivery have now done so in weeks.”

96% of psychologists now see patients virtually. This wholesale adoption of remote psychotherapy through a digital intermediary poses the question – How effective is this cyber exchange between patients and their therapist?

This blog contacted some of the behavioral health professionals we correspond with regularly and asked for their opinion. It must be noted that all the case workers we talked to were already using teletherapy, and our sample was small, so this was not a scientific study. It was just an enlightening conversation.

Therapist #1.

Based on my experience so far conducting teletherapy sessions with certain clients, my answer is generally, yes, but with some nuances. Note that I said, ‘certain clients’. Remote therapy in my practice seems to be effective with patients I’m treating for anxiety, depression, panic disorders, and eating disorders. Other patients with more severe psychiatric problems still benefit from coming into the office for face-to-face treatment.”

Therapist #2.

“I have to have a very strong relationship with a client before I risk remote therapy. If I don’t know a patient well, I find it difficult to assess their responses if I can’t look them in the eye and feel their energy face-to-face.

“Many of my patients who I do know well don’t have access to digital media that they feel comfortable using so I continue to see them in person.

“However, when I do think a patient is a candidate for teletherapy it usually produces satisfactory results over time. I’m using it now with about 25% of my clients.

Therapist #3

“My practice is confined to military veterans. As you might imagine, this population presents me with a wide array of therapeutic needs from military women’s abuse issues all the way to combat veterans suffering from PTSD. Each of these patients requires a different therapeutic approach so they all need to start out in person. Some may migrate to teletherapy after enough ‘getting to know you’ time, and some will never be supported by cyber therapy. So, I guess my answer is, ‘it depends’ on the disorder I’m treating and the patient themselves.”

The Consensus

  • Overall, our therapists seem to think in-person therapy is a slightly better clinical experience than teletherapy, but if the trade-off is therapy vs. no therapy, then teletherapy is a much better course of action.
  • They agree that the most important factor is finding a therapist with whom a patient can build a strong, trusting relationship, through whatever medium. Some patients may also benefit from a hybrid approach, coming into the office when needed and staying home for more routine check-ins.
  • They don’t think you need to be in-person every time, but you may need it sometimes. They feel psychotherapy will probably be hybrid forever.

In conclusion, these therapists suggest that teletherapy can be a highly effective form of mental health care, especially for certain conditions. Ultimately, the most important factor is finding a therapist with whom you can build a strong relationship and whose approach aligns with your needs and preferences, regardless of the delivery method.

Explore More Insights from the FAMCare Blog:FAMCare Recommend Reading

Share the Post: