Total revenue for nonprofits has seen immense growth, reporting an increase from $812 billion in 1988 to over $2.6 trillion in 2019.
The number of foundations more than doubled from just over 40,000 in 1995 to over 86,000 in 2017, with assets growing from $373.4 billion to over $1 trillion in the same period.
The sector has seen a surge in large organizations, with hundreds founded since 1970 growing to over $50 million in annual revenue. (See Note Below)
This dramatic growth is due to the almost limitless largesse of the donating public.
Donor Skepticism: When Output Metrics Fall Short
This amazing growth, however, has given rise to growing donor skepticism. As these humble nonprofit start-ups grew into massive corporate entities, donors began to wonder if these now massive nonprofits were really making the dramatic change in the quality of life their output metrics seemed to indicate. In other words, did output metrics translate into actual changes or benefits (outcomes) for beneficiaries. Impact is the difference your nonprofit makes: There’s the work you do and then there’s results that flow from it. More nonprofits, grant makers, and government partners are focusing on outcomes, rather than outputs.
Habitat for Humanity
A dramatic case history of how substantial output metrics can be misleading when it comes to intended outcomes was recently related to this blog by a retired college professor who served as the Chief Appropriate Technology Officer for Habitat for Humanity back in the 1980s.
President Carter, (who was a graduate engineer and one of the founders of Habitat), became concerned in the 1980s about whether the thousands of living structures Habitat was building in third world countries (outputs) were helping to alleviate homelessness (outcomes). Millard Fuller, the founder of Habitat, recruited our construction professor to go around the world and examine Habitat’s outputs (dwellings) to see if they were indeed accomplishing what they were intended to accomplish (alleviate homelessness).
After one year of traveling the world examining the structures that Habitat had erected, our interviewee (who has chosen to remain nameless for this blog) reported back to President Carter and Millard Fuller that a large percentage of the homes Habitat had built used “inappropriate” technology for the culture they were erected in and were, therefore, not being used by the natives as a primary residence. (e.g. Habitat had inadvertently built small concrete block houses on islands where the natives lived only in thatched lean-tos on the beach.)
Just as Jimmy Carter and Millard Fuller suspected, the vast “output” metrics (number of dwellings) Habitat had produced to date were not producing the “outcome” for which they were intended. To their credit, they had suspected this and took action to verify the data and change how Habitat went about designing and building dwellings in other than western cultures. Millard Fuller and President Carter were ahead of their time when they realized that defending outcomes in nonprofits involves proving impact through data-driven evaluation, transparent communication, and, if necessary, managing conflicts regarding performance. (Carter Work Project | Carter Work Project)
The National Council of Nonprofits
The National Council of Nonprofits and its state association network encourage nonprofits to embrace a culture that supports evaluating the difference your nonprofit is making. This requires first identifying “What does success look like?” Then making a plan that will get you there and collecting information along the way to evaluate whether your nonprofit’s progress is getting you closer to success. Finally, it’s also important to communicate what you are discovering and use those lessons to continuously improve performance. All of this is referred to variously as, “outcomes measurement,” or “performance management,” or simply, “evaluation.”
Key strategies include:
- Defining clear success metrics,
- Maintaining audit-ready financial records to counter accusations of mismanagement and using evidence to combat misinformation.
- Proactively documenting and communicating the value provided to build trust and ensure sustainability.
- Instead of just tracking activities (outputs), focus on the actual changes or benefits (outcomes) for beneficiaries.
- Regularly monitor progress, use feedback loops, and evaluate whether the organization’s actions are leading to the desired results.
- Utilize data to demonstrate impact and counter misinformation.
When Good Programs Lose Funding
This is the number one problem that must be avoided at all costs. Nonprofits must begin to distinguish outputs from outcomes and track and report this more incisive data to the donating public. Once funding is lost, it is almost impossible to replace it.
Read More on Nonprofit Impact and Reporting
Understanding the difference between outputs and outcomes is only the first step.
Organizations that succeed in today’s funding environment are those that can clearly demonstrate measurable impact.
Explore more insights on nonprofit reporting, program evaluation, and leadership in human services.
➡️ Explore More Insights
- From Outputs to Outcomes: What Funders Expect Now
- Reporting vs. Outcomes: What Funders Really Want to See
- Grant Funding in Uncertain Times: A Diversified 2026 Strategy for Nonprofits
The statistics originate from a combination of Internal Revenue Service (IRS) data analysis and research conducted by The Bridgespan Group. Specifically, these figures are widely referenced in reports analyzing the long-term growth and financial health of the U.S. nonprofit sector: 501(c)(3) Nonprofit Revenue Data: Details & Analysis
