Understanding the difference between restricted and unrestricted funds is crucial for nonprofit financial health. While restricted funds ensure donors’ wishes are honored, unrestricted funding provides the flexibility needed for long-term growth. By maintaining a healthy balance between the two, nonprofits can thrive and continue making a lasting impact.
However, the growing popularity of restricted funds over the past fifty years has quietly undermined many nonprofits’ ability to survive.
The History of Restricted Funding
Before 1969, foundations faced very few rules regarding how or when they distributed their money. The passage of the Tax Reform Act of 1969 introduced strict payout requirements and severe penalties for private foundations. To protect themselves legally and ensure compliance with complex tax codes, foundations began writing rigid, program-specific grant agreements.
In the 1970s, as philanthropy transitioned from a “give and step away” charity model into a highly structured, corporate-style system focused on measurable, short-term outcomes, this new nonprofit model encouraged more restricted donations.
During the dotcom boom, a new generation of tech-wealthy donors applied Silicon Valley venture capital principles to the social sector. This framework — known as “strategic philanthropy” or “venture philanthropy” — treated donations as business investments. Donors demanded hyper-specific data, targeted interventions, and rigid control over exactly how their capital was deployed. Restricted donations quickly became the new “savvy” way to participate in philanthropy.
As restricted grants became the dominant model, donors naturally preferred to retain power over their money even after giving it away. Restricting a grant substitutes the donor’s personal judgment for the professional expertise of the organization doing the work.
Eventually, this movement gave rise to sector watchdogs like Charity Navigator and GuideStar, who popularized the misconception that “good” nonprofits spend very little on administration. Donors began restricting funds to direct program services out of fear that their money would be “wasted” on operations, salaries, or rent. After a while, donors wanted to point to a specific, tangible outcome they could take credit for — such as building a new school wing or purchasing laptops. Unrestricted funding that pays a utility bill or health insurance for staff does not offer the same reputational reward.
The Tide Began to Turn in 2020
In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, political turmoil, and global uprisings for racial justice, funders began to reexamine their work at every level. Many dropped onerous reporting requirements. They moved money quickly, with fewer strings attached. They converted restricted grants to general operating support so nonprofits could pivot to meet unforeseen needs.
More philanthropic leaders were stepping up to do the bold, rigorous, and infinitely more rewarding work of institutional change — reimagining traditional roles and structures in radical ways, including transforming organizational cultures from corporate to community-centric. These leaders recognize nonprofit health and well-being as a major ingredient in advancing social progress.
The Charlize Theron Africa Outreach Project: A New Model
The Charlize Theron Africa Outreach Project (CTAOP) supports and partners with community-based organizations and youth on the front lines of change, focusing on sexual and reproductive health and rights and the prevention of gender-based violence.
“The long-term partnerships we develop are based on mutual respect and trust,” Charlize Theron has said. “Since those closest to the issues are the ones who are best suited to create transformative and sustainable change, CTAOP supports these powerful leaders and catalysts, our Program Partners. As funders, if we are to achieve our shared vision with our grantee partners, we need to build an environment with strong relationships, where each of us takes responsibility for our role. Too often this isn’t the case.”
Building Trust & Flexible Funding for Sustainable Impact
Through her Africa Outreach Project, Charlize Theron has helped catalyze a movement that is ta
king hold across the philanthropic community — one where grantors and grantees are engaged in partnership based on mutual respect and trust rather than rigid donor control.
The Giving USA 2026 report offers timely data that reinforces this shift. U.S. charitable giving reached $617.2 billion in 2025 — a record — driven in significant part by a nearly 20% surge in bequest giving. Bequests, by their nature, often represent the ultimate trust-based gift: a donor deciding to support an organization’s mission without restriction, because they believe in the people and the work. The Great Wealth Transfer is arriving. How that wealth gets directed — toward restricted program grants or toward trust-based operating support — will shape the nonprofit sector for a generation.
The organizations best positioned to benefit from that shift are the ones that have built funder relationships grounded in transparency, accountability, and demonstrable impact. Not restriction. Trust.
That insight will be the foundation for nonprofit success going forward.
Resources for this article:
- What the 2026 Giving USA Report Means for Nonprofit Leaders
- Giving USA 2026: Five Fundraising Realities Behind the $617 Billion Record – Winkler Group
From the Desk of Francis Bennett
Francis Bennett is a writer and human services thought leadership contributor. His work explores nonprofit leadership, social work practice, client engagement, organizational effectiveness, and the human side of helping professions.
Connect with Francis on LinkedIn.
Editor’s Note
FAMCare regularly shares perspectives from practitioners, consultants, and subject matter experts working throughout the human services community.
Related reading:
- Grant funding in uncertain times: a diversified 2026 strategy for nonprofits
- Why human services agencies lose grant renewals they should have won
- What Funders Seek in Human Services Reports: Defensible Data & Audit Readiness
- The data behind the story: why the best nonprofit narratives are built on numbers
- Enterprise capital for nonprofits: beyond traditional grants
