Thinking outside the box has become a business cliché. When we asked three nonprofit CEOs what they considered their board’s most critical task they all repeated the “outside the box” cliché in one form or another.
Primarily for legal reasons, the nonprofit Board of Directors has become, almost exclusively, a governing body that selects the CEO and approves annual budgets and major capital expenditures. Nonprofit CEOs, however, are beginning to look to their boards for a consulting as well as a governing function. When a nonprofit Board of Directors is structured with leaders experienced in legal, marketing, organizational, and financial matters their input can and should provide the organization’s strategic impetus. The collective wisdom of experienced leaders is the most important contribution a Board of Directors can make to a nonprofit’s mission success.
The Nonprofit Board’s Proper Function
The three CEOs we corresponded with agreed that a fully functioning nonprofit Board of Directors should be responsible:
- To create a governance system that serves the nonprofit’s mission.
- To perform a strategic analysis that positions the organization for growth through change.
- To develop the core capabilities, operational alignment, and external alliances to execute the strategy and fulfill the organization’s mission.
- To author effective performance management systems
Organizations seeking to strengthen governance practices can also reference widely accepted nonprofit board guidance published by sector leaders such as the National Council of Nonprofits: Good Governance Policies for Nonprofits | National Council of Nonprofits
Most nonprofit missions are conceived and inspired by a founder who recognized a societal need and crafted a unique way to serve that need. As nonprofit organizations succeed and grow, the ability to adapt the original service model to shifting and expanding needs and circumstances begins to outstrip one person’s creative capability. Nonprofits then tend to morph into rigid institutions that can lose touch with their constituents. A carefully structured Board of Directors can take up the slack and craft the strategic direction of a growing organization.
What a Living Strategy Looks Like
Perhaps the best example of ongoing strategic thinking guiding an organization comes from the “for profit” segment. Steve Jobs, the founder of Apple, was best known for his unique strategic approach to managing his business. For Jobs, strategic thinking was a way of everyday living. He didn’t conceive his strategy in one step and carve it in stone, he lived it (and expected his team to live it) every day. He focused on intense prioritization, minimalism, and aligning product, people, and culture rather than top-down financial goals. His core strategy was summarized by, “If you do the right things on the top line, the bottom line will follow”. He famously utilized the “Rule of 3” to simplify complex messages, narrowed product lines to a few “perfect” items, and emphasized user experience over cost-cutting.
Key elements of Steve Jobs’ strategy included:
- Jobs ruthlessly cut Apple’s product line upon his return, focusing on a 2×2 matrix (consumer/pro, desktop/portable).
- He prioritized creating the “right” products and building the “right” culture, believing that if these were achieved, profitability (the bottom line) would inevitably follow.
- Strategy was driven by design, functionality, and consumer appeal rather than profit maximization.
- He dedicated 80% of his time to critical tasks (signal) and only 20% to less important matters (noise).
- He used, and expected his team to use, simple, visual, collaborative brainstorming to create a clear, strategic message.
- Jobs famously believed that customers could not tell him what they wanted until he showed them, allowing him to create entirely new markets.
- He emphasized that strategy is not just about a plan, but having the right team in place to execute it.
Research from organizations like NTEN also shows that technology and data visibility increasingly influence how nonprofit leaders plan, evaluate programs, and report outcomes: 2022 Data Empowerment Report|NTEN
Think “Outside the Box”
Imagine Steve Jobs sitting on your nonprofit board. How would he impact your nonprofit’s strategic approach? Ponder that question carefully. You may find it has a profound impact on your organization’s strategic impetus.
Strengthening Strategy with Better Insight
Strategic boards rely on clear, timely information to guide decisions and measure impact. If your organization is working to improve reporting, accountability, or program visibility, we’ve gathered practical guidance to help.

