The History of Juvenile Justice in the United States

History and juvenile justice written on a chalkboard, representing educational insights into case management in juvenile justice.

The juvenile justice system that has been evolving in the United States over the last 125 years is largely a mystery to everyday Americans. Most seem to understand that “minors” are not held responsible for misdeeds to the same degree that the courts adjudicate adult conduct. Many, however, have no idea how this has played out within our complicated criminal justice system or are they aware of the role the social work community has played in the evolution.

Juvenile Delinquents

  • Baby Boomers think that we simply send offending minors to “reform school”.
  • Gen Z and Millennials think the courts just give juvenile offenders a slap on the wrist and send the little miscreants home.
  • Both views overlook the empathetic approach to juvenile justice that has evolved into the modern system through the concerted, relentless effort of our social work community.

In the Beginning

In 1825, social activists Thomas Eddy and John Griscom opposed the common practice of incarcerating youth during their formative years with adult offenders because the practice was simply creating more criminals. Their work led to the establishment of the New York House of Refuge in 1825, the first institution designed to house poor, destitute and vagrant youth who were deemed by authorities to be on the path towards delinquency. The New York House of Refuge was the first significant event in what was to later become the juvenile justice system. (“Juvenile Justice History | Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice – CJCJ”)

Juvenile Court

In 1899, with the establishment of the first juvenile court in Chicago, the juvenile justice system began to formally diverge from the adult system. “The juvenile court became the unifying entity that led to a juvenile justice system.” (“Juvenile Justice History | Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice – CJCJ”) Prior to this, children were prosecuted and punished as adults, but this new court, influenced by the early social work community’s ideas of rehabilitation and individualized justice, created a separate system focused on the unique needs and capacities of youth.

Parens Patriae

The Cook County Juvenile Court was founded on the principle of “parens patriae” (the State as Parent). The new court assumed the right to intervene on behalf of youth deemed to need help based on their life circumstances or their delinquent acts. The primary motive of the juvenile court was to provide rehabilitation and protective supervision for youth.

Reform Schools

At this time, social reformers began arguing for a new type of corrective institution that placed greater emphasis on education. Through this movement, the reform school, (Delinquent Children: The Juvenile Reform School (From Oxford History of the Prison: The Practice of Punishment in Western Society, P 363-389, 1995, Norval Morris and David J Rothman, eds. — See NCJ-167509) | Office of Justice Programs) also called training and industrial schools, became an indelible part of America’s juvenile justice system. Today, they are typically called youth correctional institutions and continue to follow a classic congregate institutional model.

Evolving Juvenile Justice

 By the mid-1920s all states had established separate juvenile justice. The new system featured informal, private court proceedings and created separate facilities and probation systems for juveniles. The goal was to investigate the reasons for a child’s delinquent behavior and provide services to guide them toward a productive path.

1950s

By the 1950s and 60s, social workers were becoming concerned about the effectiveness of the juvenile justice system because of the disparities in treatment that resulted from the absolute discretion of juvenile court judges. Similarly situated youths could receive vastly different sentences based on the mood, temperament, or personal philosophy of individual judges.

1960s

In the 1960s, through the concerted efforts of the social work community, the Supreme Court made a series of decisions that formalized the juvenile courts and introduced more due process protections such as right to counsel. Formal hearings were required in situations where youth faced transfer to adult court and/or a period of long-term institutional confinement.

1980s and 1990s

  • In the late 1980s, many states began to pass punitive laws, including mandatory sentences and automatic adult court transfer for certain crimes.
  • In the 1990s, this tough on crime trend accelerated. Tougher laws made it easier to transfer youth offenders to the criminal justice system, and the dividing line between juvenile and adult justice began to blur again.
  • Beginning in the late 1990s, the drive to increase rates of youth incarceration began to recede. Led by the California social work community, many states began reducing the number of youths committed to youth correctional institutions.

 21st Century

  • By the end of the first decade of the 21st century, states such as California were instituting the most sweeping reforms in the history of the juvenile justice system.
  • The social work community has fought a tireless battle on behalf of empathetic juvenile justice. Many thanks to social work policy leaders for their clear thinking and dedicated advocacy over the years.

Additional Resources on The History of Juvenile Justice:

Explore More Insights from the FAMCare Blog

Share the Post: